Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rypke Zeilmaker's avatar

Again excellent post, that confirms that the classical 'conspiracy'-villains of the internet, R&R ARE the perpetrators, but the Dutch play a leading role as well. Regarding 'nature risk', In The Netherlands we see this mechanism at work, where policy risk and litigation risk (as in Carney's lecture) are combined to rob farmers of their land, payed by the public, caused by 'public interest litigation' of an ngo (Mobilisation for the Environment, MOB), forcing the government to take 'nitrogen deposition' (calculated from a model) into account in Natura 2000 areas. In this way large tracts of farmers land, aka Natural Assets, are bought up and end up into the hands of a few large conservation ngo's, with the use of Nitrogenmodel Aerius and a risknumber to a desired Natura 2000-vegetation (critical nitrogen load) in an area that experts claim is in an 'unsustainable state of conservation.' The leader of MOB was awarded for his services (not knighthood as in Britain but something less official) by the King of the Netherlands for his work (destroying thousands of farmers futures)

Rypke Zeilmaker's avatar

Also check out on Ben Caldecott:

https://www.smithschool.ox.ac.uk/person/dr-ben-caldecott/

" ...as a Trustee of the Commonwealth Climate and Law Initiative (CCLI) which he co-founded, from 2015 to 2023. CCLI examines the legal basis for directors and trustees to consider, manage, and report on climate-related risk, and the circumstances in which they may be liable for failing to do so."

Again, the Dutch pioneered in climate litigation, the famous Urgenda case against the Dutch taxpayer. Urgenda started the Climate Litigation Network afterwards with British support:

Sarah Mead: IUCN World Commission on Environmental Law, with their handbook ‘Fighting Climate Change: a best practice guide for Judges and Courts’ uit.

Co-director Lucy Maxwell, London School of Economics.

April Williamson, de Senior Legal Associate Climate Litigation Network, from ClientEarth Climate Accountability and Climate Finance Teams.

Friends of the Earth NL was also succesfull against Shell

But you Brits already had Client Earth since 2007 of James Thornton, which now cooperates with Urgenda in the CLN, funded by Childrens Investment Fund (Chris Hohn), Bloomberg and Rockefeller Philantropies

Their German offshoot is Germanwatch

With hindsight you see the broader picture of this strategy. They help advocate the 'risk' of litigation, while they are funded in doing so by billionaire foundations and the government, the same that invented this 'risk' and that push for the policies

Best from Friesland, Rypke.

18 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?